LifeLine Essential Clip On Mudguard Review: Easy To Fit And More Effective Than Expected

I’ve had a revelation. And it involves my arse.

As a result of being a bit more committed to riding when the weather is filthy (partly in order to find opportunities to test high performance outer wear), I’ve tended to return from rides with mud and ‘road juice’ sprayed up my back and my backside.

I think US readers may refer to this as the ‘buttside’, but I am not sure.

The gunk hasn’t only covered my person. It’s covered my bike.

Whilst I’ve been good (“good girl Daddy” as our youngest proclaims) at rinsing down the bike after each ride, it isn’t ideal having megatons of megacrud splatter-gunned all over the rear, whether it’s mine, or that of the bike.

Oooh, What Could The Solution Be, Mont…?

Thank you for asking.

Now, much as I’d love to draw out the suspenders further, the somewhat banal ‘revelation’ is that I’ve bought a new easy-to-install – and effective – rear mudguard. Profound.

I’ve used mudguards (perhaps ‘fenders’ to US folk) before.

For my old bike (the trusty Dawes) I bought a set of SKS Raceblades, which I used for one winter season (or maybe a couple).

The Raceblades were straightforward to fit, using plastic mounts that, themselves, were attached to the bike with the same thick rubber bands used to fix Garmin handlebar mounts. They were effective as well, at least in terms of protecting me from spray.

The main issue with the Raceblades was the noise. Or rather the cause of the noise.

On a relatively frequent basis, the mudguards would rub against the wheels. I am sure this additional resistance resulted in a loss of wattage, or really a loss of speed for the same wattage, and I have neither an abundance of watts nor speed that I can risk losing.

Every so often I’d have to get off the bike in order to fiddle with the guards to stop them rubbing. Which. Was. Annoying.

Once I took the Raceblades off one summer, I never quite got round to attaching them again. Then I bought a replacement bike (my Trek Domane) in 2013, and I’ve ridden sans guards ever since.

Until now.

The Moment Of Clarity

I was driving to work in mid-December. I had spent the entire journey ruminating on my dirty bottom problem. As one does.

I pulled up at some traffic lights in front of a gym in almost-central Birmingham. Someone had locked their road bike (which they presumably used for commuting) to the railings.

The bike had a rear mudguard of the sort I assumed were only seen on mountain bikes.

I’d barely parked my car (hush now, I live too far away to commute by bike) before I was a-Googling (or a-Wiggling) on the subject.

Lo!

They (you know, theymanufacturers!) make a clip on rear mudguard for ROAD bikes! Who knew?

Given it was only a fiver (in English pounds – your currency may vary), reader I bought one.

And waited for my dirty bottom problem to be solved.

Satisfaction Delayed

Of course, me being me, the box containing the mudguard sat unopened in my bedroom for weeks whilst I continued to use my bike. In the wet. In spite of the mud. Moron.

I finally got round to fitting it on a very cold day at the end of December.

***We interupt this broadcast to bring you this important anecdote ***

In fact it was so cold on ‘fitting the mudguard day’ that the ride that day lasted all of about 4 minutes and 500 metres, before the realisation that, with the quantity of ice (both black and white) on the road, a late Christmas present of a broken collarbone and (worse) a broken bike were on the cards.

Ice ice baby

I ended up setting up my (trusty) Dawes on the indoor trainer. Which I put on the patio. And thus completed my first outdoor indoor trainer ride for many years.

turbo on patio

***Important anecdote over. Normal service resumes ***

Er, back to the show?

The LifeLine Essentials Clip On Rear Mudguard

So what do you get in the box … er, not-a-box?

LifeLine mudguard

It’s a pretty straightforward piece of plastic, attached to a bracket that you tighten around the bike seat post. There is a little hinged arm thingummy that allows some flexibility on how the mudguard is positioned over the rear wheel.

Mudguard arm

The bracket that attaches to your seat post is tightened with the aid of a Philips screwdriver. The two pivot points that you can use to position the mudguard at the optimal angle and distance from your wheel are adjusted by finger-tightening the dials, which in turn tighten the bolts that lock the joints into position.

LifeLine Essentials Mudguard fitted

LifeLine (or Wiggle I suppose, as it’s their brand) supply a few different sized collars to allow the mudguard to be fitted to a range of different diameter seat posts:

mudguard spacers

I imagine this is obvious from the photos, but I’ll say it anyway. I don’t think the guard would attach successfully to seat posts that are not round in profile – for example, aero posts with more of a tear drop profile (#aero).

What Does It Look Like?

As we all know, aesthetics are clearly more important than functionality when selecting accoutrements for your bike. However, once you’ve made the decision to prioritise a dry Aris over a sleek velo, you have to accept some visual compromises.

fitted mudguard

I wouldn’t say the LifeLine rear mudguard is the most attractive thing you can attach to your steed. I guess it looks okay. It’s pretty simple and sort of levitates above your rear wheel.

rear mudguard on bike

It’s sort of like a quizzical eyebrow, raised jauntily above the rear wheel. A flourish with a playwright’s quil. Hercule Poirot’s waxed mustache.

Of course, I already sully the clean lines of my Trek Domane with a cheeky saddlebag. You will be pleased to notice that the mudguard can be fitted quite comfortably alongside the saddlebag (or perhaps vice versa).

mudguard fitted with saddlebag

So, Does It Work?

Ah, the £5 question.

As mentioned above, my first test ride with mudguard lasted all of 4 minutes and 23 seconds:

(My ‘privacy zone’ on Strava makes the ride look even shorter…)

Any potential (and, let’s face it, hypothetical, given how far away the guard sits from the wheel) rubbing noise, was drowned out by my silent terror-screams as I realised quite how icy it was.

It was also dry.

I got the opportunity to test it properly a couple of days later, when the road conditions (or at least my drive conditions) looked a little like this:

muddy wet day

I am pleased to report the following:

  1. When I cock my leg to mount the bike, sometimes my foot, or lower leg, catches the mudguard as I go up and over. This isn’t really a problem. The mudguard (fender…) seems quite substantial (as far as plastic can) and I haven’t knocked it out of alignment with the rear wheel. It’s just a slight annoyance and totally avoidable if I remember to give it the full scissor-kick bike mount technique (what, you don’t know that one…?).
  2. There is no rubbing. Have you looked at the photos? There would have to be serious mudguard droop to get anywhere near the rear wheel.
  3. And most importantly…. the mudguard works!

Here is the ‘after’ from the aforementioned test ride:

mud on bike

You will note how cruddy the brakes, rear seat stays, the seat post and the wheel are. You might also note how clean the top of the mudguard is.

And this cleanliness extends to the ‘protection area’, which you will now please to enjoy:

clean bum mudguard

The things I do for this blog…

I also got my wife to take a photo of the full back region. There’s a bit of spattering (from mud!) on the lower leg and a touch on the inner thigh […silence…].mudguard clean bottom But generally a good result. My gilet (the blue thing) barely needs hanging up. Pre-mudguard rides saw it receiving frequent goes through the washing machine.

Fin

Here ends my highly technical ‘review’ of the LifeLine clip-on rear mudguard. It was dead easy to fit and seems to do the job. It probably diminishes the look of the bike. But then I don’t spend most (any) of my ride staring intently at my rear wheel.

If you would like to buy one (and support the blog, as this is an affiliate link), click here to see the mudguard on Wiggle (the link will take you to the store in your country).

Alternatively, if you’re American and Wiggle means nothing to you, click here to see an equivalent rear fender on Amazon, coincidentally made by SKS (the makers of the Raceblades above).

Right, who else is a mudguard fan (my starting question at dinner parties)? Any recommendations? Front and back? Let us know in the comments below.

11 thoughts on “LifeLine Essential Clip On Mudguard Review: Easy To Fit And More Effective Than Expected

  1. I went hrough multiple mudguards including SKS Raceblades and some other SKS products, that I didn’t like. For basic protection, I use ass saver from Decathlon. Costs maybe 3 Euro. If I want slightly better protection I put on Zefal Swan. Around 15 Euro in Decathlon for a pair, front/back. I’ve been using it for a long time. It’s very simple and effective.

  2. Does your Domane not come with “real” Mud Guard mounting points?

    I upgraded the SKS RaceBlades on my 2017 Domane SL to SKS Bluemel’s (No, I have no idea where that awful name comes from) and it’s a revelation. No more rubbing mudguards…not yet anyway 😉

    The added bonus of full size mudguards is that it also reduces the crap hitting your bike.

  3. I’ve had an SKS S-blade for a few years, it does the job in winter (and in fact wet rides in summer).
    Useful when riding in a group as well, many clubs insist on mud guards in the winter, otherwise you have to go at the back.

  4. Doesn’t look bad Mont, and besides, would anyone outside on such a crappy day, be that aesthetic-driven? Also, you pick up multiple Gent Points by any mates following you. Myself, I’m lucky to have found an old bike to dedicate to crap weather/road salt/mud etc. It sports the ancient-yet-spiff Blumels fore&aft. So very heavy.

  5. Nice bum, Monty, and you’ll be more welcome on the group rides now..but what about your front? I don’t see any form of guard there-were you OK, whatever? Or perhaps your not bothered by the odd splash/splodge or two. Does the rear LifeLine model have a front sibling?

  6. Ahhh, the joys of a dry bum! Use mine often when riding near home. Easy to remove for bike transport of leaving unattended in the city. Many styles available to suit ones tastes. Thanks for the descriptive review.

  7. Mudguards cause debates of biblical proportions in my club. I have a nice wiggle clip on. It keeps me dry. The issue with this sort of mudguard occurs when riding in a group. The mudguard acts like the splash plate on a slurry spreader – thereby ensuing a wide distribution of mud on the rider behind me.

  8. Crudcatchers for me on my carbon, full length and keep the crap of the front derailleur

    My very early (August) Xmas present – a Kinesis GFTI Disc, sports full mudguards. I wouldn’t be without mudguards, summer roads in Derbyshire can be just as filthy as winter.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.